RE: EDIT
Having posted this on Twitter and Facebook, I was moved that David Leddy had read this review and sent me some comments! Taking them into account, I’ve changed some thoughts I had and have edited accordingly. My humblest apologies for any offence caused!!
Sub Rosa
Gothic, creepy, unsettling. It’s grotesque. A complete masterpiece. *****

Having seen David Leddy’s multi-award winning “Sub Rosa” once before, I arrived at the Fringe with sky-high expectations and I was not to be disappointed! Sure, I was preparing in my head to review and yes, no-one’s perfect (sorry Mr Leddy!) and so there were one or two points which grated. But they were miniscule. I’m a huge fan, and I was irresistibly drawn into the seductively dark world which Leddy creates. I loved the adaptation of the script to fit the Masonic Lodge and truly, truly impressed by the stellar cast, who were rightly competitors for the “Best Acting Ensemble Award” in ‘The Stage Awards for Acting Excellence’. Hard luck on their loss, but congratulations on the Angel award!
Because of my love for script, location and cast, I’ll talk about the bad stuff first. I’m trying to be as balanced as possible, but they truly are tiny points.
1. Václav
SORT OUT YOUR PAUSES! There felt like far too many. If that is the actor’s interpretation, fair
enough, but I think it could have flowed better. Also, I was disappointed to feel a few times that he froze rather than paused and I did think once he had forgotten his line.
Despite this…he is my preferred actor for the strongman and he did a truly wonderful job. I don’t want this point to seem like I thought he was bad, cos…he really, really wasn’t!
2. Angus MacNeil’s Tea-Drinking
This one did wind me up. I have a personal bug-bear with this one, because I’ve managed it onstage and I’m an amateur!
HIS CUP WAS EMPTY. Not only that, but I walked past his cup (sitting in the middle of a table) to sit in front of him. It’s a tiny point, but…something in the cup is not hard. Or sitting the cup somewhere the audience can’t see inside it?
Having said all this, he remembered to swallow, and timed it perfectly, which impressed me and pretty much made up for the empty teacup.
EDIT ALERT! Apparently there was MEANT to be something in the teacup. My humblest apologies. Everyone makes prop mistakes like that from time to time and this makes the perfectly timed swallow more impressive. Sincere apologies.
(Set restrictions meant that the footstomp had to go, which is infact a shame cos it was really effective.)
3. Setting the Scene
Now, this probably isn’t a poor point to cast, director or lighting director as the venue was borrowed and I presume there were restrictions on it. However, I found the lighting rigs (and an amp in clear view, guys!) a little distracting.
This was the main point that David Leddy dealt with in his email. I felt really bad when I read it, to be true, cos I should have seen his point from the start. Again. may I offer apologies if I seemed at all negative here! Let me leave you with the words of the man himself. “Sub Rosa is a piece about seeing behind the theatrical illusion, not about creating an immersive Victorian environment. Hence me shining light on the workings, not hiding them. Sub Rosa exists in several places at once, in the Winter Palace , in the Masonic Lodge (or the Citz), in a Fringe theatre venue and implicitly in all theatres at once. It is very important to me that we slip between those worlds rather than create a Victorian film set, which would be obvious and banal.”
Also, when I glanced to the back of the hall (looking around the impressive room) during Ida McCracken’s speech, I did want to kill the sound engineer standing up in plain view. Tut tut.
Aaaaaaaaaaaargh, I feel like such a dissenter! I’m sorry! That’s all, I promise! On to raving about it, right away! Now, anyone who knows me knows that I am, as far as performance goes, a perfectionist. And, frankly, I’m a snob. I confess them both. My first words of praise need to go to Mr David Leddy, playwright, director and general extraordinaire.
I read Shakespeare for fun. I take note of a good playwright, and Leddy is better than most. Every word, every stomach-turning phrase of Sub Rosa is selected with skill and care. For example, when I saw at least three people in my group flinch or shudder at how “You can still recognise him, from the dark, rosy scar where Flora tore away half his cheek with her teeth.” If it had been “You can still recognise him, from the scar where Flora bit his face.” the impact
wouldn’t have been there. Leddy is a master and has crafted an incredible world. Anyone who has seen (or even read) Sub Rosa can’t quite explain why we are all so enchanted – obsessed – with such a gruesome piece of work, but those inside the world of Sub Rosa comprehend it perfectly. He’s a true inspiration – if I can ever write anything half as good as David Leddy
A nod to the guides. Now, I love the guides. Something about their eerie, quiet presence just sets the whole scene. They’re tricksy though! >>SPOILER ALERT!!<< I had been totally taken in by the history of the Citizens Theatre, and was delightedly shocked to discover upon on the script that it was all fake. I was awaiting the falsified history of the Masonic Lodge (fascinatingly drawn) and couldn’t help but feel smug as I watched the other audience members lap it up. Then I started listening to an online interview with David Leddy about the play (you can check it out here: http://www.theatrevoice.com/listen_now/player/?audioID=887) to discover that no, it didn’t take over a year of struggle with the Masonic brothers, the City Council and the Fire Department, it all happened pretty smoothly. Mr Leddy, you got me again. >>hat off. END SPOILER.<<
And now for the cast. Well, let me point out first that it’s a hellish challenge to be so close to such an intimate little audience, to monologue for so long, in such an intense atmosphere and do sevenish shows a night, particularly when you don’t start until 10.20pm! Sub Rosa is from the offset a challenge for any actor. This cast rose to it spectacularly. I was enchanted, drawing on their every word, reliving my first adoration for the play afresh as the actors looked me in the eyes and reeled off their tales. I was moved by the sheer, exhausting intensity of their emotion – angry at the injustices they described, laughing at the Merkeley sisters’ antics (and Václav’s decoupage), feeling my heart wrench for the wig master. And afraid. Constantly afraid. Heart racing, breath catching in my throat, at once exhilarated and terrified. Every single cast member was incredible, and all truly set a standard to attain for a wannabe like me.

Particularly I have to give a nod to Claire Dargo, playing Ida McCracken, a bitter, wounded, terrified chorus girl and (thus) a gentlewoman of lenient virtue. I would dearly love to play Ida McCracken one day, and if I ever did Ms. Dargo would be the standard I would look up to. Without even the aids of movement that the other actors used (she sat in a chair throughout) she had me totally entranced, she was just incredible. And even though I knew the story, when the ending came and she leapt up, her terror, the look in her eyes had my heart trying to break free of my ribs. I couldn’t take my eyes off the ceiling, and I truly don’t think I’ve ever seen anything more chilling than her exit under the illuminated and eerily glowing:
“Brotherly love, relief and truth.”
Even sitting at my computer, remembering it now, I feel like I’m being watched. Truly amazing. Well done all.
* * * * *
Sub Rosa Credits
Adam McNamara – Svaty Václav, a Continental strongman, contortionist and posturer. 
Angele Darcy and Isabelle Joss – Millie and Dillie Merkeley, patter artistes and Siamese twin princesses.
Benny Young – Angus MacNeil, a wig master and widower of misanthropical countenance.
Isabella Jarrett – Mrs Thorn, an ageing mother in reduced but respectable circumstances.
Claire Dargo – Ida McCracken, a chorine and (thus) a gentlewoman of lenient virtue.
Guides – Sharon Beck, Edd Crawley, Leanne Foxwell, Matt Lacoste and Lynsey-Anne Moffat.
A Fire Exit production, in association with Citizens Theatre, Glasgow
David Leddy – writer, director, rehearsal blogger and all-round in chargey.
Producer – Di Robson of DREAM
Production Manager – Chris McDougall
Stage Manager – Laura Walshe
Lighting Design – Nich Smith
Sound Design – Graham Sutherland
Dramaturg (what is that exactly?) – Douglas Maxwell
Design Assistant – Stef Smith
Associate Producer for DREAM – Niloufer Sagar
Junior Producer for Fire Exit – Mhairi Hetherington
Public Relations – Liz Smith
LED Lighting – Artistic Licence
“It is dangerous to be right when those in Power are wrong.“